To judge a man by his external behaviour alone is akin to judging a man by his clothes - both can be misleading. Up until a few minutes ago, Edward Reynold was considered guilty by everyone at the nominating meeting. Guilty with having "done away" with Elizabeth Neal his ex-fiance, in order to hide the truth forever. There were any number of suspicious indications all pointing to him, but at that very moment, Reynolds car was seen pulling up before the town hall. Why did he come back?