Hundreds of thousands of American readers will remember Bruce Marshall's books, The World, the Flesh, and Father Smith, and Father Malachy's Miracle. The other day, Mr Marshall's latest novel was released for publication called Vespers in Vienna. The critics are divided on Mr Marshall's newest book, none more so than the critics of today's show, Mr Charles Paulding who is the literary editor of the Commonweal magazine, and William Kernan, the executive secretary for The Institute for American Democracy and well known Episcopal clergyman.