Broadcast: January 9, 1954

Starring: Howard McNear, John Dehner, William Conrad, Georgia Ellis, Parley Baer, Sam Edwards, Norman Macdonnell, Herb Ellis, Helen Kleeb, Ted Bliss, George Walsh, Rex Koury, John Meston

Added: May 29 2020

Jake and his men have caught the man that has been stealing their horses. Tillman is Jake's neighbor and they've known each other for a long time. Jake caught Tillman red-handed, he was herding the horses away from the farm, even though he claims that he was trying to drive them all home and that one had got away. Tillman said that Jennings saw him herding the horses up, but Jake doesn't wait to ask him, and hangs him...